The Problem of Low-Wage Jobs

John Schmitt discusses "Low-wage Lessons" inwards a Jan 2012 newspaper written for the Center for Economic together with Policy Research.

Define "low-wage jobs" equally those that postulate earning two-thirds or less of the median hourly wage: that is, those earning less than nigh $10/hour. As Schmitt notes: "If low-wage operate were a short-term Earth that helped connect labor-market entrants or re-entrants to longer-term, well-paid employment, high shares of low-wage operate would survive less of a social concern. Indeed, if low-wage operate facilitated transitions from unemployment to well-paid jobs, countries mightiness desire to encourage the creation of a low-wage sector to better workers’ welfare inwards the long term." On the other side, if low-wage jobs are a near-permanent Earth of affairs for a substantial grouping of workers, or if such jobs fifty-fifty transportation a negative signal to potential futurity employers that this worker is going to bring depression productivity, together with so the prevalence of low-wage jobs may survive of existent policy concern.

Given the rising levels of inequality inwards the U.S. economic scheme inwards recent decades, it's non a big surprise that the part of workers who tin survive classified equally "low-wage" has been rising, from nigh 22% of the workforce inwards 1979 to nigh 28% of the workforce past times 2009.


Moreover, the part of U.S. workers who are low-wage is considerably higher than inwards many other high-income countries. About one-quarter of U.S. workers are low-wage, compared amongst 20-21% inwards the UK, Canada together with Germany; nigh 15% inwards Japan; together with 8% inwards Kingdom of Norway together with Italy.

The number hither tin survive summed upward amongst this question: If someone inwards the U.S. economic scheme is a law-abiding citizen who plant full-time for a current of years, tin they earn a degree of payoff that allow them afford a spell of middle-class measure of living? If you lot are earning $10/hour together with working 2,000 hours per year, your annual earnings of $20,000 would set you lot below the poverty line of $22,891 for a unmarried rear amongst iii children

And the problems of low-wage operate aren't express to depression wages. Schmitt writes: "Not exclusively are low-wage workers probable to rest inwards low-wage jobs from i twelvemonth to the next, they are likewise to a greater extent than probable than workers inwards higher-wage jobs to autumn into unemployment or to move out the task forcefulness altogether. ... U.S. task police line offers workers remarkably few protections. U.S. workers, for example, bring the lowest degree of work safety inwards the OECD together with no legal correct to paid vacations, paid sick days, or paid parental leave. ... [M]ore than one-half (54 percent) of workers inwards the bottom wage quintile did non bring employer-provided wellness insurance together with to a greater extent than than one-third (37 percent) had no wellness insurance of whatever kind, someone or public."

It's worth noting that task forcefulness participation rates for men aged 16-24 bring fallen from 72% inwards 1990 to 57% inwards 2010, together with for men from 25-54, the task forcefulness participation charge per unit of measurement has fallen from 93% inwards 1990 to 89% inwards 2010, according to Bureau of Labor Statistic data.  Much of this is due to the depression pay available to those amongst depression science levels.


Schmitt exclusively sketches his policy suggestions here, which include higher rates of unionization, higher minimum wages, employment-protection legislation together with other national task laws, along amongst higher benefits for the jobless together with low-income households. He less of a fan of the Earned Income Tax Credit, fearing that employers capture much of the produce goodness of the credit because it allows them to pay lower payoff than they otherwise would. For my ain part, dramatically higher rates of unionization would wing inwards the confront of a half-century tendency inwards the U.S. (see this post for to a greater extent than or less details).  While I'm comfortable amongst the minimum wage playing to a greater extent than or less role inwards the task market, jacking it upward past times 50% or to a greater extent than seems to me unwise.  I'm an enthusiastic supporter of the EITC, together with a cautious supporter of certainly national legislation to better work benefits together with conditions.

But my role hither is non to fence policy, simply exclusively to indicate out that the U.S. task marketplace seems to survive producing an final result where a substantial together with growing proportion of full-time employees earn barely plenty to creep to a higher house the poverty line. If nosotros wishing to ready a lodge together with an economic scheme on rewarding work, it is a harsh fact of U.S. task markets that such a vantage is currently non apparent for many.